1 and 4 feel very strong to me, which fits her really well I think ^^
But I also like 2 and 3 for their dynamic 🤪 what a dilemma haha.
I would choose 1 over 4 I guess, bc the composition could generate a very mysterious look, with the pigeons flying around her, covering small parts of her.
Hmmm even tho I like 1 the most, it might be better to pick 2 at least for the illustration, bc for the challenge they should be attacking/defending and therefore the second one probably is more fitting.
Man I'm glad I'm not the one who have to decide, they are all very well executed xD