Hey guys, this a fairly quick painting I did for a school project. I spent about 8 hours on it. It's not as polished as it would be if it was a personal piece but I would love to get some critiques. I'm hoping to do a lot more painting over the summer so if I could find some of the biggest flaws with my paintings then it wil greatly help me in the future. Thank You!

Hi William! I like the concept you have going here. Very mysterious! The blue and red lighting is a great touch.

Regarding areas of improvement, there are three main things that stand out to me. First, the eyes look a little flat. This is where studying anatomy really helps. Eyeballs are spherical and need to be shaded that way to look realistic. I trick I've used before is to make a circle selection in Photoshop and shade the entire eyeball separately before masking out the eyelids over it.

Second is skin tones. Generally, you never want to use 100% white or 100% black on skin. Instead, go for light yellows, browns, and blues for highlights and dark purples, blues, and browns for shadows. Again, reference is super helpful. You'd be amazed how many weird colors skin has.

The last thing is detail. Normally, you want the crisp, tight details to be the most important part of the painting. Right now the smoke in the background is the sharpest, drawing my eye away from the looser brush strokes around the woman's face. I'd recommend tightening up her hair and eyes some more and blurring out the smoke to bring the focal point back to her face.

Finally, here's a quick paintover to show what I mean. Hopefully that was helpful! Keep up the good work :smile:

Thanks for the feedback! The paint over is really helpful. I definitely see what you mean about the background detail. I know that too much detail in the background detracts from the focal point but when I added the smoke I didn't think about it. I really like the adjustments you made to the eyes. I noticed you adjusted their shape as well. I also like the rim light you added to the hood, it adds a nice touch.
Thanks for the Feedback, I'll definitely keep it in mind on future projects.