I like version 2 because it's more unique! Also you can make her even shorter, like in your first drawing (4-th character). I love the idea to give her a GIANT weapon to make it like cutie "no way she's able to lift THAT up" girl)
I don't know: you don't give her a bagpipe, it's a good move to avoid clichรฉ, or you need to use it... This decision is up to you)