Thanks for the input guys!
First one does fit the theme the best but its a bit generic in my opinion.
That's a really though decision, i detailed each one more but i still cant decide.

What would you guys take?

I also like 2. 3 is neat too. I just like things dark and creepy XD

2 and 3 are very intriguing and would give you alot more to play with in terms of character detail and story. The 1st concept looks really cool but it reminds me of Gears of War. Can't wait to see the final result!

My fav is 2. Can be more convincing & tactile, as I see it. GL!

Yea 2 & 3, 2 if you can make it something more, idk maybe the thing behind her more than just a pile of people? looks like that to me.
3, can be really cool looking, i like the mysterious shadow people/hands surrounding her. For me something is missing for both 2 & 3 idk what it is though.

Thanks everyone for your feedback!
thats still a really though decision
Definitly right, in terms of design and story 2&3 are better

I love the second one, the earth design, very different and has an ominous feeling to it. Like you said the first one is a bit generic, but what you did there with the red accent (blood i think) of the earth painting is very original, i think if you push it a bit further it could be something really awesome!

I like the third illustration. Cool idea with hands.

Absolutely love that first one, really intimidating! Great work so far :smiley:

Well that's still a though decision, IG followers voted for nr2 but it was pretty close with nr1.
I am currently working on nr2, if i am not happy with the final result; or time is left im going to finish nr1 too. than decide which one im going to submit.

Thanks everyone for your input on this!
Anybody got some ideas to improve this; at the current stage?

Tough decision but they're all fantastic! This is looking amazing so far too, love the concept.

This is a very grim visual, I love it.

It's hard what to say or improve as you had a clear vision in mind. The only thing I can think of is her pose being a little too symmetrical. Maybe try adjusting the position of her limbs a little to see if it improves? For example, maybe bend the legs a little but have one bent more than the other, since she's floating. Or maybe bend her fingers a little different from each other so it's not the same pose on each side.

Now that tj mentioned it, I didn't even know she was floating so I'd say that definitely should show more!

hard decision, the colors are incredible, maybe if you add something bright, something that adds another light source to focus the view at that point

Small update; i changed the hands a bit and the legs like tj mentioned.
i also pushed the floor a bit more down, maybe its clearer now that she floats.
Im still unsure about the design, will focus on that later.
Will also add a bit of light at the top later.

This is already looking clearer, and yes it does read better that she floats now! Your values are looking really wonderful, it's a really beautiful piece in both concept and application. One of my faves